Ref NoGSL/COM/P/4/2/44
TitleReferees’ report: H CUMING, “Valparaison earthquake”
Date10 Jan 1836
LevelItem
Extent1 letter/item
FormatDocument
DescriptionReferees’ report: H CUMING, “Valparaison earthquake.” No report by Adam SEDGWICK, 10 Jan 1836
Administrative HistoryThe paper referred to the earthquake of November 1822, which was the subject of Maria Graham's paper “An Account of some Effects of the late Earthquakes in Chili”, 'Transactions of the Geological Society' (1824).

The earthquake became the focus of George Bellas Greenough's 1834 Anniversary Address. Greenough disagreed with Charles Lyell's assertion of the elevation of land by earthquakes, which Lyell had written about in his book 'Principles of Geology'. However, instead of directly attacking the author, Greenough took issue with one of the eyewitness accounts which Lyell cited - that of Maria Graham [later Lady Maria Callcott]. Lady Callcott took exception to being called a liar, and published a vigorous defence in 1834. The controversy rolled on for another year or so, this being one of the accounts which disputed Graham's statements.
Access ConditionsAccess is by appointment only. Please contact the Archivist for further information.
LanguageEnglish
Publication NotePaper is likely to be that read before the Society on 2 December 1835, and published in the Proceedings of the Geological Society, vol 2, pp213-214.
ArchNoteDescription by John Thackray
SubjectReferee reports
Publishing
Earthquakes
TermPublishing
Previous referenceCOM/P 4/2/44
Persons
CodePersonNameDates
DS/UK/8GREENOUGH; George Bellas (1778-1855); geologist1778-1855
DS/UK/2108CALLCOTT; Lady; Maria (1785-1842); née Dundas; other married name Graham; travel writer1785-1842
Places
CodePlaceName
NA310Chile
NA389South America
    Powered by CalmView© 2008-2024