Ref NoLDGSL/838/L/17/16
TitleMurchison correspondence: letter from Charles LYELL
Date15 Mar 1834
LevelItem
Extent1 letter
FormatDocument
DescriptionMurchison correspondence: letter from Charles LYELL, London, 15 Mar 1834. Re: false impression created on novices of Greenough's opposition to the concept of land elevation due to earthquakes; reprinting the first edition of 'Principles of Geology' with slight edits, is working on the second edition but does not want to announce it as the publisher still has copies left of volume 3; asks for any marginal notes for the second edition, W H Fitton has already supplied over 1200.
Thumbnail

e4\aafe24-9d6f-4eee-b3b9-8abe5120e42d.jpg

58\b673cc-a6dc-4092-bd37-4f502af74619.jpg

15\ad5468-932c-45c3-b725-57b2c9ecd231.jpg

1d\3c9429-36f3-4952-ad65-b77f08cd916f.jpg

Administrative HistoryThe reference to George Bellas Greenough concerns the subject of his Presidential Address in February 1834. Greenough disagreed with Charles Lyell's assertion of the elevation of land by earthquakes, which Lyell had written about in his book 'Principles of Geology'. However, instead of directly attacking the author, Greenough took issue with one of the eyewitness accounts which Lyell cited - that of Maria Graham [later Lady Maria Callcott]. Graham's paper “An Account of some Effects of the late Earthquakes in Chili”, had been published in the 'Transactions of the Geological Society' in 1824.

Lady Callcott took exception to being called a liar, and published a vigorous defence in 1834. The controversy rolled on for another year or so, resulting in other papers on the subject of earthquakes or raised beaches being sent to the Society.
Access ConditionsAccess is by appointment only. Please contact the Archivist for further information.
LanguageEnglish
ArchNoteDescription by John Thackray; revised by Caroline Lam
CreatorNameLYELL | Sir | Charles | 1797-1875 | 1st baronet | geologist
Previous referenceLDGSL 838/M/L17
Persons
CodePersonNameDates
DS/UK/16LYELL; Sir; Charles (1797-1875); 1st baronet; geologist1797-1875
DS/UK/8GREENOUGH; George Bellas (1778-1855); geologist1778-1855
DS/UK/2108CALLCOTT; Lady; Maria (1785-1842); née Dundas; other married name Graham; travel writer1785-1842
DS/UK/77FITTON; William Henry (1780-1861); physician and geologist1780-1861
DS/UK/2MURCHISON; Sir; Roderick Impey (1792-1871); Baronet; geologist and geographer1792-1871
    Powered by CalmView© 2008-2024